LinkedIn comment drafter

Why three drafts, and why those three types?

The structure isn't arbitrary. Across thousands of warming sequences run by WarmList users, three comment shapes show up repeatedly as the ones that consistently clear the "this is recruiter spam" filter and land as authentic engagement:

Question. Asks a sharp follow-up that extends the post's argument or pushes it toward a specifics. Best when the post is a confident claim that has natural follow-ups. The candidate replies because answering is easier than ignoring.

Value-add. Offers a data point, an experience report, or an alternative framing. Best when the post is a thoughtful observation and you have something concrete to add. Builds credibility — the candidate sees you as a peer with relevant context.

Congratulations / amplify. Acknowledges the post's value and makes it social. Best when the post is announcement-shaped (promotion, launch, milestone). Lower informational density but high signal of "this person noticed me," which is what warming is about.